The prompt wants a fruit or vegetable whose name starts with A, E, I, O or U. Apple and orange are the two everyone writes — both are far from the top tier.
Aim for something real and specific but rarely written down. The top tier on this prompt is reached by answers the game’s curators had to dig for — naming a famous, obvious example usually lands you far below 100.
Before you submit an answer, ask whether it would appear in a dictionary, a wiki page or a list a curator could scrape. If yes, it is probably not deep enough.